Book cover I Am Not a Serial Killer by Dan WellsA 15-year old boy named John Wayne Cleaver, a diagnosed sociopath obsessed with serial killers, who used to torture animals, loves fire and still battles incontinence, seems better suited for the role of “villain” but Dan Wells proves the opposite in his debut novel, I Am Not a Serial Killer.

What I Liked Most

The exploration of man’s duality: good and evil living within the same being and the choice whether man indulges the “wrong” urges or denies them for the “right” ones. Perhaps this inner struggle is why people are so smitten with characters like Dexter Morgan and Hannibal Lecter, who are, by most definitions, “bad” people. Yet we can’t get enough of them or their stories. Why? We always hope, against all odds, the bad person can change – that they can be redeemed – and the “good” person we know is in there, will prevail. Plus, thanks to their writers, they’re likeable.

And John Wayne Cleaver is likeable with his sharp humor, witty observations and devotion to making the “good” choice.

What I Liked Least

First know, I’ve read this book twice because the below threw me for such a loop last year that I had to give the story another chance. Now I’m going to do for you, those who haven’t already read the book, what the author should’ve done:


Yes, that’s right: The author spoiled his own surprise. And a really good one, I might add. For three chapters Wells builds mystery and suspense around the murders and the killer. But then, while John examines a victim’s body, Wells writes,

While we waited, I studied the slashes in the body’s abdomen. They were certainly animalistic, and one area on its left side had what looked like a claw mark — four ragged slits, about an inch apart, that extended nearly a foot toward the belly. This was the work of the demon, of course, though we still didn’t know that at the time. How could we? Back then, none of us even suspected that demons were real. I placed my own hand over the marks and guessed that whoever made them had a hand much bigger than mine. (Chapter 3, Page 52)

Uh, what?!

Not the best reveal ever and it seems to come from an omniscient source because in the next sentence John is guessing about the killer again. I was jolted out of the story by those three sentences; however, I kept reading. But Wells continued the story as if the above never happened. So, four chapters later on page 103, there was only mild surprise when, in what I assume was supposed to be the big TA-DA, the killer’s identity is revealed. It just wasn’t as exciting as it could’ve been had the above passage been cut.

Final Thoughts

Overall, as a debut novel in young adult literature, I Am Not a Serial Killer offers readers something different and entertaining. I have a soft spot when it comes to books for teens, especially in the horror genre, and I feel there’s potential with Dan Wells. He’s certainly not shy about splashes of gore here and there. I look forward to reading the rest of the trilogy. But please, no more spoilers!

Learn more about Dan Wells and his books at


Eileen · August 2, 2011 at 7:09 PM

Well, I must say I do have a soft spot for Hannibal Lector and am fascinated by the dual nature. Guilty as charged. I haven’t watched Dexter, but plan to eventually. I’ve heard good things.

That spoiler is pretty glaring. Amazing it got through agents, editors, etc. Or, do they think teens wouldn’t notice? It’s confusing. But, if the author has good chops in important other areas, then there’s hope yet.

    Leah · August 2, 2011 at 8:13 PM

    I thought maybe I was turning into one of “those” readers, which is why I read it again. But then I was like, no, it’s a definite spoiler and just doesn’t fit into that scene. Glad you could see where I was coming from.

    P.S. Dexter, the Showtime series, was based on / adapted from Darkly Dreaming Dexter by Jeff Lindsay. So if you haven’t watched the TV show yet I’d advise giving the book (and its sequels) a read. Then switch to the show. I own all four seasons and the fifth is pre-ordered 🙂 Every summer I gotta have my Dexter and True Blood fix.

      Eileen · August 19, 2011 at 12:17 PM

      Dexter was a book, huh? I’ll mention it to my daughter too.

      Funny thing about True Blood: I can’t stand the show. I watched the first 3 episodes and then other ones here and there, hoping to get into it, but just couldn’t. I love the books too much, I guess.

      I like the actors they have for Sookie and Bill, but can’t stand Eric. I really don’t want to see who they have for the fairy (sorry, can’t remember her name) because I have this really powerful image in mind for her (same problem with Eric).

      Plus, for some reason, the sex scenes jar me out of the story. I knew what it would be like going into it (it’s on HBO, after all) but perhaps it’s the way it’s filmed? I’m not normally squeemish, or a prude, for that matter, but it just really turned me off. Go figure.

        Leah · August 23, 2011 at 12:53 PM

        Claudine is Sookie’s fairy godmother, and I know what you mean. She did not live up to my imagination’s vision so you probably should not watch 😉

        I felt about Eric how you do, at first. Then as the story morphed and progressed he grew on me. After season one I decided I had to draw a solid, permanent line between the TV show and the books because they are two different worlds now. That, I think, is how I’ve managed to get into the show.

        By the way, the only actors to match my imagination are Joe Manganiello and Kristin Bauer who play Alcide and Pam, respectively.

I Am Not a Serial Killer (2016) – Unleash the Flying Monkeys! · January 14, 2017 at 6:59 PM

[…] thoughts: Years back I read the young adult book on which this movie was based. It was a solid story, one I knew had the potential to be an […]

Leave a Comment

Related Posts


Eleanor by Jason Gurley

Rating: 4.5 of 5 Now available in paperback. Eleanor is the story of one woman’s choice and its ripple effects across the lives of her descendants. Young Eleanor’s mission, looking back through her life to Read more…


Things We Lost in the Fire: Stories by Mariana Enríquez

Rating: 3 of 5 Coming soon! February 21, 2017 Available to pre-order now. A collection of short stories set in Argentina, filled with macabre imagery and abhorrent behavior, none of which will leave you feeling Read more…


The Revised Fundamentals of Caregiving by Jonathan Evison

Rating: 3.5 of 5 “Listen to me: everything you think you know, every relationship you’ve ever taken for granted, every plan or possibility you’ve ever hatched, every conceit or endeavor you’ve ever concocted, can be Read more…

%d bloggers like this: